For international students working toward a PhD, planning a second master's degree, or thinking about changing majors, the biggest worry of the past few months has been having to ask USCIS for more time after year four. On November 16, 2026, that worry eased: a federal court formally struck down the rule.
1. What the Court Decided
On July 17, 2026, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) published a final rule that would have ended "duration of status" (D/S) for F-1 students, J-1 exchange visitors, and their dependents. Under D/S, which has been in place for decades, a student may stay in the United States as long as they maintain status and make normal progress toward completing their program. The rule would have replaced it with fixed admission periods of up to four years, after which students would have to apply to USCIS for an extension. Representatives of foreign information media (I visas) were also covered.
A coalition of higher education groups and labor unions sued, and on September 14, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts postponed the rule's effective date. On November 16, the court issued its final decision: it granted the plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment and vacated the entire rule under the Administrative Procedure Act, finding it arbitrary, capricious, and otherwise not in accordance with law.
In one sentence: The rule never took effect, and the court has now struck it down in full. F-1 and J-1 students remain under the existing D/S framework.
2. Why the Court Struck Down the Rule
The court adopted the analysis from its September decision. It found that DHS failed to properly weigh the rule's costs and benefits, relied on fraud and national security rationales that did not support the rule, overlooked less burdensome alternatives, and did not adequately respond to significant public comments.
In its final decision, the court added two more grounds:
- Existing tools could do the job. The government already operates the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS). The court found that DHS never explained how requiring students who have already studied in the U.S. for four years to go through an unreviewable, completely discretionary renewal process would meaningfully improve its ability to detect fraud, and that DHS failed to weigh the alternative of enhancing SEVIS.
- Limits on academic choices conflict with what Congress intended. The court noted that, under DHS's view of an appropriate "course of study," the rule would restrict extended study (such as the years a PhD requires), joint degrees, changes of academic concentration, and programs that are not at a higher level than one already completed (the so-called "second master's" limit). The court held that the purpose of the F-1 visa is to permit and encourage foreign students to study in the United States, that these limits are not reasonably related to that purpose, and that DHS lacks the authority to undermine the F-1 program this way.
As for the remedy, DHS asked the court to send the rule back to the agency without vacating it. The court declined: D/S has existed for decades and the rule never took effect, so vacating it would not be disruptive.
3. Scenarios: Grace's Situation
Grace is an F-1 student in the third year of a computer science PhD at a U.S. university. Her program typically takes six years, and she is considering an MBA after she graduates.
Scenario 1: Does Grace need to apply to USCIS for an extension when she reaches year four?
Background: Under the vacated rule, Grace's admission would have been capped at four years, and she would have needed a separate USCIS extension to stay for years five and six.
Analysis: No. With the rule vacated, Grace remains in D/S. As long as she maintains full-time student status and makes normal progress, she may stay until her program is complete. If her program needs more time than the end date on her I-20, her school's Designated School Official (DSO) can extend the program under the current process.
Scenario 2: If Grace wants an MBA after her PhD, or switches to a joint degree, will she face restrictions?
Background: The rule would have restricted programs at or below the level of a degree already completed, as well as joint degrees and changes of major.
Analysis: Those limits fall with the rule. The court specifically noted that DHS itself acknowledged there are legitimate reasons to pursue, for example, an MBA after a J.D. Grace's academic plans need only meet her school's requirements and the existing F-1 rules. She should also continue to maintain status as usual: stay enrolled full time, keep her I-20 information up to date, confirm any change of major, transfer, or program extension with her DSO in advance, and keep records of each step.
Scenario 3: Could the outcome change if the government appeals?
Background: The administration is widely expected to appeal. As of the decision, the government's appeal of the September postponement order was still pending before the First Circuit.
Analysis: It could. Depending on what DHS does next, the earlier appeal may become moot, or the government may seek review of the final judgment. Unless a higher court pauses or reverses this decision, D/S remains in place.
Attorney note: This is a district court decision, and the litigation may not be over. Watch for appeal developments over the coming months, and avoid making hard-to-reverse long-term plans based on this ruling alone.
4. Can Students Now Pursue a Same-Level Second Master's or Day 1 CPT?
With the rule vacated, many students are asking whether they can now enroll in a second master's degree at the same level, or in a "Day 1 CPT" program that allows work from the first day of study.
The rule's own restrictions are gone. The vacated rule would have barred enrollment in a degree program at a level already completed, barred graduate students from changing their degree program or educational objective, and shortened the post-completion grace period from 60 days to 30. All of these fall with the rule: a same-level second master's is no longer prohibited by it, and the grace period after completing a program remains 60 days.
But the existing requirements and risks of Day 1 CPT have not changed:
- CPT must be part of the curriculum. The work must relate directly to the field of study and be authorized by the school as a course requirement. Day 1 CPT relies on an exception for programs that require practical training from the start.
- A separate CPT rule may be coming. DHS has indicated it may propose a separate regulation strengthening the documentation needed to show that CPT is integral to the curriculum. That is distinct from the vacated rule and is not affected by this decision.
- Future filings may draw questions. Day 1 CPT programs and back-to-back degrees at the same level have long drawn attention in visa interviews and in H-1B and green card adjudications, with the focus on whether the studies are genuine and the work authorized.
- An appeal could change the outcome. If a higher court pauses or reverses the decision, the same-level restriction could return.
Attorney note: If you are considering a same-level second master's or a Day 1 CPT program, choose an accredited school with a real course schedule, attend classes as required, make sure the work matches your field of study, and keep your syllabi, CPT authorizations, and work records. Whether it is the right choice depends on your academic background and career plans.
5. What to Do Now
- Keep maintaining your F-1 or J-1 status. Stay enrolled full time and keep your I-20 or DS-2019 information current. D/S has always depended on maintaining status and making normal progress.
- Do not file any extension with USCIS. The rule's extension process no longer exists. If your studies need more time, work with your school's DSO under the current process.
- Move ahead with your academic plans. A PhD, a second master's, a joint degree, or a change of major can proceed under your school's requirements.
- Follow the appeal. If the government appeals and asks for a stay of the judgment, things could change. Watch for updates from your school's international student office and from us.
- Keep your academic and immigration records. Your I-20 or DS-2019, transcripts, and enrollment verifications will be useful for any future immigration filing.
Conclusion
From the rule's release in July to its vacatur in November, D/S has been through a turbulent stretch, and for now students keep the ability to stay until their programs are complete. The litigation may continue, and every student's stage and plans are different. When policy is uncertain, getting the basics of maintaining status right matters most.
The LYD Law immigration team can help students and exchange visitors review their current status, assess how plans such as a PhD, a second master's, or a change of major affect their status, and map out post-graduation paths through OPT, H-1B, or a green card. If you have questions about your period of stay or next steps, we welcome you to contact us to develop a plan based on your situation.